The 2025 NAC Football Awards recognize the standout players and coaches from across the Northeastern Athletic Conference following the conclusion of the Fall 2025 season. All-Conference selections, the NAC Football Player of the Year, and the NAC Football Coach of the Year are determined by conference coaches and reflect the highest level of individual achievement in NAC play. The honorees below represent the best of small-school football in Northeast Ohio for the 2025–2026 school year.
All-NAC Football 2025
- Fairport – Brady Lawson, Yomar Castellano, DJ Dambolena, Jan Castellano, Trey Vaughn, Abraham Castellano, Cale Milliman, Shane Greenwood
- Pymatuning Valley – Sean Croston, Jayce Fulkman, Alex Simon, Stuart Jenick, Chase Guysinger, Justin Britton, Kasen Bailey
- St. John – Chase Newsome, Anthony Severino, Frankie Dubsky, Milo Twining, Carlo Fasano, Gus Petros
- Grand Valley – Jay Anthony Williams, Luke Giddings, Lukah Mramor, Austin Miller, Jeremiah Corll
- Mathews – Drew Spagnoletta, Jim Pegg, Cody Denman, Logan Deak
- Windham – Matt Kolaczek, DeJuan Ramsey, Azeon Davis
- Cardinal – Jaiden Fix, Mason Thistlethwaite
All-NAC Football 2025 – Honorable Mention
- Fairport – Elijah Harless, Brandon Gibson
- Pymatuning Valley – Donald Obhof, Max Smith
- St. John – Makade Kanicki, Anthony Petrochello
- Grand Valley – Carter Turk, Mason Kocab
- Mathews – Anthony Coursen, Dane Brubaker
- Windham – Alex Eye, Bryan Smithberger
- Cardinal – Xzavier Apathy, Axel Young